Legacy Card Co. logo

Beyond the Case

Services

A card shop is more than a shelf of product. This is everything else we do — most of it starting with a conversation at the counter, not a checkout button.

Buy, Sell & Trade

Bring in singles, sets, or a full collection — we'll make a fair offer on the spot, in cash or store credit.

  • Walk-in offers on individual cards, binders, or full collections — no appointment needed for anything under $2,000 in estimated value
  • Store credit bonus (typically +10%) if you'd rather stock up than cash out
  • Estate and inherited collections handled with care — we'll walk you through what's actually there before any offer is made
  • We buy sports and TCG alike: raw, graded, and sealed

Consignment

Let us sell your higher-value cards in the case or online — you set the floor, we handle the buyer.

  • Best for graded cards and vintage pieces worth more sold individually than bought in bulk
  • Standard commission is 20%, reduced to 10% for Vault members
  • Listed in the physical case and on our online shop simultaneously
  • You're paid out within 5 business days of sale

Grading Submissions

We batch member and walk-in submissions into our own bulk PSA/BGS/SGC orders every month.

  • Free pre-screening for centering, surface, and corners before you commit to a submission tier
  • Bulk-rate turnaround and pricing — you pay the grading company's bulk rate, we don't mark it up
  • Monthly submission window, first Sunday of the month (see Events)
  • We track your submission and notify you the moment slabs are back

Group & Case Breaks

Pick your team or set, we crack the case live in the lounge (or streamed), and hits ship straight to you.

  • Weekly sports breaks (team-pick and randomized formats) and periodic TCG box breaks
  • Run live in the lounge and streamed for members who can't make it in
  • Everything pulled for your slot is yours — no minimums beyond your entry
  • Group discount pricing on breaks booked for 8+ people (birthdays, work outings, etc.)

Appraisals & Estate Buys

Inherited a collection or found one in a closet? We'll tell you honestly what's in it and what it's worth.

  • Free walk-in appraisals for collections under 500 cards; by-appointment for larger estates
  • We travel for verified estate collections over a certain size — ask when you call
  • Written appraisal available for insurance or estate purposes (fee applies)
  • No obligation to sell — plenty of people just want to know what they've got

Custom Orders & Want Lists

Chasing a specific card for a set or a PC? Leave it on your want list and we'll flag it the moment it comes through the door.

  • We check every incoming collection and trade-in against active want lists before it hits the case
  • Members get first right of refusal on want-list matches for 48 hours
  • No limit on how many cards you can have on file

Organized Play

Sanctioned and casual tournaments across Pokémon, Magic, One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and Lorcana, every week.

  • Certified to run sanctioned Pokémon League Cups and Yu-Gi-Oh! Regional Qualifiers
  • Weekly Standard, Commander, and sealed formats, plus casual League nights for newer players
  • Prize support in packs, store credit, and promo cards
  • See the full calendar on Events

Vault Storage

A monitored, insured space to keep the graded cards you're not ready to display or sell.

  • Included for Vault-tier members, up to 25 graded cards
  • Climate-controlled, access-logged storage on-site
  • Pull a card for viewing or sale any time we're open, no notice required
  • Available as a standalone add-on for non-members by request

Got a collection sitting in a closet?

Bring it in for a free walk-in appraisal, no obligation to sell. Estate collections and larger consignments, ask about scheduling an appointment.

Prefer to browse first? See what’s in the case.